The new Gangs of Gotham series spinning out of Batman: Bad Seeds is an exploration of Gotham’s appropriately seedy underworld, featuring a duo of unlikely protagonists plucked from the nineties. One you may know as the Cluemaster’s daughter and the only crimefighter to serve as both Batgirl and Robin, Stephanie Brown. The other is…Lonnie Machin, a complicated young vigilante who has been an enemy to the Bat-Family more often than an ally. Known mainly as Anarky to his friends and enemies alike, this conspiratorially minded crusader against authority is one of the most divisive figures among Batman fans, but certainly not without his passionate defenders. For those not yet familiar, allow us to introduce you.

Inspired by V for Vendetta, Spy vs. Spy and the young anarchists of Judge Dredd, Lonnie Machin was designed in the wake of Jason Todd’s passing in Death in the Family to add a new youthful presence in Batman’s life from a different angle than the traditional Robin role provided. The desire was to reflect the growing anarchy movement in Britain at the time, home of creators Alan Grant and Norm Breyfogle. That movement, according to Grant, represented his own early ideals that justice in a radical realignment of society was a prerequisite for progress against an authoritarian regime.

A hero in his own mind, though one with perhaps a tendency to take his ideals too far without thinking them all the way through, Anarky was introduced to provide a challenge to the system of order that Batman had sworn to protect…and perhaps to examine that, maybe, the people deserve a little more power.

As initially introduced in Detective Comics #608-609’s “Anarky in Gotham City,” Lonnie’s gimmick was that he used a mask and artificial lifts to make himself appear older than he seemed. In truth, he was a twelve-year-old vigilante who took cases based on cries for help left as letters to the editor in the Gotham City newspaper, taking it upon himself to carry out the will of the people.

Anarky went on from that debut to make irregular appearances in Alan Grant’s Batman work, particularly in his ongoing Shadow of the Bat series, where he played unlikely ally to Batman as often as foil. From there, he got his first of two self-titled series in 1997, where Anarky brought his style of radical liberation to Apokolips—and scored a Mother Box of his own in the process. His second series took him beneath the Washington Monument in the nation’s capital, making himself a problem for the federal government as he left the No Man’s Land-stricken Gotham to Batman. During his stay in DC, Anarky got into all manner of hijinks like temporarily commandeering a Green Lantern ring, and even an exploration of the idea that his own father may actually be the Joker—a notion which, to this day, remains unconfirmed.

Following his second series, Anarky mainly disappeared for a while. Alan Grant supposed, when asked, that the need for a younger perspective in Batman’s circle had been filled by Tim Drake. In the 2000s, Robin writer Fabian Nicieza had a similar notion—and so, late in the run of Robin’s ongoing solo series beginning with issue #181, and continuing into his subsequent Red Robin series, Anarky returned, reimagined as a foil not for Batman, but for his more traditionally minded peer in Tim Drake.

Following Flashpoint, a variety of new incarnations of Anarky sprouted up in various Batman titles during the New 52 period, and in adaptations wider afield. Perhaps his largest role of the decade was in Seasons 4 and 5 of Arrow, reimagined as a psychotic killer under the employ of overarching villain Damien Darhk, until Oliver’s sister Thea disfigures him, leading to an even more dramatic break in his psyche which turned him against Darhk’s H.I.V.E. organization.

In James Tynion’s 2016 run on Detective Comics, the classic Anarky returned as a figure independent of the Bat-Family establishing his own grassroots campaign to enact a new form of justice in Gotham, for which he attempted to recruit current Gangs of Gotham costar Stephanie Brown. That was the most we’ve seen of him of late…save for a tie-in to the 2021 Fear State event in I Am Batman, where he was apparently killed by a citizen Mask Hunter.

Exactly how Anarky survived that, we don’t know. But he began appearing in small cameos after his believed demise as early as 2022. Maybe that Mother Box he picked up back in 1997 had something to do with it. But as of Batman: Bad Seeds, he’s out in the streets again fighting for his vision of a Gotham that belongs to Gothamites.

More than once when asked about his creation, Alan Grant used to say that, had events gone another way, he could have seen Lonnie becoming the third Robin. Now, Gangs of Gotham might just give us a closer look at what that world might have been like. All things considered, we think we could use a little Anarky.
 

Gangs of Gotham #1 by Christopher Cantwell, Mike Henderson and Trish Mulvihill is now available in print and as a digital comic book.

Alex Jaffe is the author of our monthly "Ask the Question" column and writes about TV, movies, comics and superhero history for DC.com. Follow him on Bluesky at @AlexJaffe and find him in the DC Official Discord server as HubCityQuestion.