DC All Access is taking “Versus” to a whole new level as we pit two of DC’s most iconic characters against each other and try to determine who would win in a fight…live! For this debut segment, we’re tackling the biggest, most enduring match-up of them all: Superman vs. Batman! DC writer and host Sam Humphries welcomes writer Jon Rivera (CAVE CARSON HAS AN INTERSTELLAR EYE) and Nerdist’s Dan Casey as they debate which of the two star superheroes would come out on top. Would Superman’s strength and strong array of powers send Batman limping back to his cave? Or would the Dark Knight’s ingenuity, resourcefulness and preparation knock the Man of Steel back down to Earth? They debate who would win, but you make the final call by voting in our poll below!

Voting results will be tallied at 9:59 a.m. PST on Monday, May 7th. To make sure they’re counted, get your votes in prior to then!

Care to elaborate? Let us know who you voted for and why in the comments!